I have used every iPhone and I have used several Android phones (since there are
11,000 of them out there, I cannot physically use every Android phone). While part of that has to do with my job, I am simply a hopeless geek fanboy and always want to try all of the latest and greatest.
Android is making some good strides, but I still use an iPhone as my daily driver and have ever since they came out. HTC One is a close second, based on its build quality and its decent screen. It's too big for one handed use, though, and runs Android. Otherwise, it would be a killer phone for me.
The iPhone has a well-designed user interface that is consistent across most of the platform. Once you learn the ins and outs of what the core apps do, you can pretty much figure out how any third-party app works (provided it's designed thoughtfully). The look and feel is very stable, intuitive, and fluid, all the way back to the original iPhone. Apple made sure to get that right before they started adding anything else. They've done that the whole time, holding back on features until they felt they fit with the rest of the system.
Sometimes they
missed the
mark, sure, nobody's perfect. But the core of the experience is to be responsive and easy to use. That never faltered, even if specific features left something to be desired. And they never, ever have carrier crapware. Apple bucked that trend by enforcing a single user experience across all of their phones no matter what carrier.
Android started with more features at the expense of a cohesive experience. They gradually came to realize the fluidity of the UI mattered (my guess is once they hired Matias Duarte away from Palm), so they started addressing that back in Android 4.1 or so. There's still so much of it that lacks refinement, though, and I constantly run into one or two things a day on Android that remind me why it's still not my main phone. There are too many cooks in the kitchen. If you manage to figure out one part of Android, watch out, because the next part will take something you learned there and turn it upside down. This is somewhat mitigated by making sure you get a "Google experience" device, but even then, there are still different experiences within the same first-party features.
Good Android phones are hard to come by, you basically have to go out of your way to get them. The vast majority is bogged down with crappy manufacturer customizations that add bloat, differentiate the experience, and make it that much harder to figure out. I have the Note 2 and it's chock full of half-baked software that isn't very well thought out. Then there's the carrier, who often tacks on their own crapware on top of what the manufacturer does. Android is basically the cell phone carrier's best friend--they can do whatever they want with it, because it is "open." That makes it a nightmare to try and support, because you have an infinite number of combinations of hardware, apps, and use cases. Just ask anyone who's tried to develop an app or an accessory for Android. I'm up to my eyeballs in compatibility issues between my hardware and Android devices, the Galaxy S3 being one of the culprits, and there are no fewer than 20 different SKUs of the Galaxy S3 that might behave differently than the Galaxy S3 I have here.
Plus, I don't want to settle for lesser hardware just to get a screen size that I can use with one hand (4" is pushing it as it is), so that rules out every Android phone for the last 2 years. All of the top of the line phones are ending up at 4.7" or higher. In the 4.3" or smaller screen size range, they stick last-generation processors with crippled GPUs. I game on my phones, so having less than top of the line hardware means I get less than a stellar gaming experience.
With each new iPhone, I get a top of the line piece of hardware in a usable screen size. There's always the haters that say the S stands for same, Apple isn't innovating, etc. This is not exclusive to the iPhone 5S. Every iPhone before it was criticized for being too similar to the last one. Well, they already reinvented the wheel in 2007. They can't do that every year. They are suffering from the same problem Microsoft faces with Windows - it's so popular that it is difficult and dangerous to do too many different things with it from one revision to the next. Despite that, they still pack an amazing amount of improvements each time when you get down to it.
The 64-bit processor is an impressive leap itself. Doubling the speed of the phone every year as they have over the last 3 years, that's nothing to sneeze at. Plus, a fingerprint sensor that's actually usable. And a better camera without having one of those ugly bumps on the back. And a coprocessor to more efficiently handle motion data. This is pretty decent stuff from a hardware standpoint.
If you want to talk about same, just look at Samsung - the original Note is a bigger S2. The Note 2 is a bigger S3. The S4 is a smaller Note 2. The Note 3 is a bigger S4. Yawn. They own half of the Android market because they sandblast it with every screen size imaginable, with features packed in for the sake of having more features. They don't have very good focus, so they can't make one or two products stand out as clear winners. What little focus they do have is on all the wrong things, "look how much technology we can pack into this phone," rather than "look at what we can do with this technology." These are problems that many Android manufacturers have.
I remember my Atrix, which touted the world's first dual core processor in a phone, and sported a fingerprint sensor, of sorts. It was hilariously bad. Enrolling my fingerprint into the Atrix involved about 20 minutes of farting around with it trying to swipe not too fast, not too slow, but just right. Then, when I wanted to unlock the phone. I needed to press that button and then swipe it, not too fast, not too slow, but just right. Usually two or three times. And that dual core processor went to waste with Android.
Given that, I'm more looking forward to the iPhone 5S than the Note 3. I am intrigued by the rumors of the Nexus 5, but it looks like it's going to be Yet Another Giant Ass Phone. I think it will take an enormous, concerted effort from all of the captains to steer Android in the right direction for the kind of phone I want. Either that, or through sheer luck or brute force, someone like HTC will hit another one out of the park with great hardware design and pair it with a version of Android that won't make me want to stab somebody.