2019 R-F Race Ratings

Discussion in 'NASCAR chat' started by ToyYoda, Feb 13, 2019.

  1. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Once again, I'll be keeping track of the average ratings we give the races in the "Rate the Race" threads here. I'll be doing this with the same guidelines as usual...

    - Races will be counted on a 1-10 scale. If your rating is less than 1, it'll be counted as a 1. If it's more than 10, it'll be counted as a 10.

    - Only race ratings will be counted, ratings for the broadcast or the winner will not. So, ratings like "A 10 because Harvick won" won't count.

    - You will have to have seen at least most of the race for the rating to count. Ratings like "I only saw the last 10 laps, but I give it a 9" won't go into the average.

    - Overly convoluted ratings won't count. For example, a rating like "I give Stage 1 a 7, Stage 2 a 4, and Stage 3 a 6 except for the last 10 laps, which were a 9" won't be counted.

    - Ratings will only be counted out two decimal places. So in other words, a 7.71459875257 will be a 7.71.

    - The highest and lowest ratings will be dropped. This helps counter the "always a 1" or "always a 10" voters. If a race gets three 10" ratings, two of them will count toward the average

    - I'm only tracking points paying races. Exhibition races like the All-Star Race or the Duels won't be part of this, although I will post the averages for those individual races.

    As mentioned above, I'm not including the Clash in the rankings, but it got a whopping 3.03 average rating based on our votes.

    Here's to hoping for a better year than that! :D
     
    Clutch, FLRacingFan, Turtle84 and 4 others like this.
  2. Johali

    Johali Team Owner Contributor

    Thanks again for doing this bud. :beerbang:
     
    ToyYoda likes this.
  3. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    My pleasure! :cheers:
     
    Johali likes this.
  4. Charlie Spencer

    Charlie Spencer Remember the Gator

    StandOnIt, Johali and ToyYoda like this.
  5. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Here's the full Speedweeks scorecard:

    Clash: 3.03
    Duel 1: 4.62
    Duel 2: 5.29
    Truck Race: 7.67
    Xfinity Race: 3.25
    Daytona 500: 7.79

    Next week I'll start having the season-long rankings for the Cup and Xfinity races.
     
  6. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97

    2. Daytona (2/17): 7.79

    Xfinity:

    1. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65

    2. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
    Kiante, LewTheShoe, Johali and 3 others like this.
  7. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    2. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    3. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21

    Xfinity:

    1. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40

    2. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    3. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  8. Kiante

    Kiante Team Owner

    Nice consistency to start off the season IMHO.
     
  9. Best start of quality races to start a season in a while IMO
    hope Phoenix keeps it up
     
    SlicedBread22 and ToyYoda like this.
  10. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    2. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    3. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    4. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21

    Xfinity:

    1. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    2. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    3. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    4. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  11. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Fontana was both the best and the worst race of the year so far....

    Cup:

    1. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    2. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    3. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    4. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    5. Fontana (3/17): 4.41

    Xfinity:

    1. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    2. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    3. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    4. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    5. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  12. Kiante

    Kiante Team Owner

    Holy schmoly what a difference.
     
    Charlie Spencer and ToyYoda like this.
  13. Johali

    Johali Team Owner Contributor

    I'm glad to see that you stumbled through that mess to get an average. :eek:
     
    Larsonfan1995 and ToyYoda like this.
  14. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    My head hurts now, but I got there. :D
     
    Charlie Spencer and Johali like this.
  15. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Yeah, this was really the first turd race of the year on the Cup side, all the others have been pretty good. Fortunately, we’ve got Martinsville coming up this weekend.
     
    TexasRaceLady and Johali like this.
  16. TexasRaceLady

    TexasRaceLady Plank Owner Contributor

    Quite a spread.
     
    ToyYoda and Johali like this.
  17. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    2. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    3. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    4. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    5. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    6. Fontana (3/17): 4.41
     
    IanMcVittie and Charlie Spencer like this.
  18. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    2. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    3. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    4. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    5. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    6. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    7. Fontana (3/17): 4.41

    Xfinity:

    1. Texas (3/30): 7.60

    2. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    3. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    4. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    5. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    6. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
    Charlie Spencer and LewTheShoe like this.
  19. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Bristol now way out in front in both series'.

    Cup:

    1. Bristol (4/7): 8.82

    2. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    3. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    4. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    5. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    6. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    7. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    8. Fontana (3/17): 4.41

    Xfinity:

    1. Bristol (4/6): 8.52

    2. Texas (3/30): 7.60
    3. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    4. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    5. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    6. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    7. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  20. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Bristol (4/7): 8.82
    2. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    3. Richmond (4/13): 7.86
    4. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    5. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    6. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    7. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    8. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    9. Fontana (3/17): 4.41

    Xfinity:

    1. Bristol (4/6): 8.52
    2. Richmond (4/12): 8.14
    3. Texas (3/30): 7.60
    4. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    5. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    6. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    7. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    8. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  21. Speedbowl14

    Speedbowl14 Ryan Preece and short tracks

    Hmmm...the three package tracks at the bottom...maybe NASCAR should re-think that gen 7 plan of basing that car off of this year's "package" car...
     
  22. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Bristol (4/7): 8.82
    2. Talladega (4/28): 8.62
    3. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    4. Richmond (4/13): 7.86
    5. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    6. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    7. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    8. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    9. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    10. Fontana (3/17): 4.41

    Xfinity:

    1. Bristol (4/6): 8.52
    2. Talladega (4/27): 8.16
    3. Richmond (4/12): 8.14
    4. Texas (3/30): 7.60
    5. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    6. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    7. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    8. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    9. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  23. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Waited an extra day to post these since it was a Monday Cup race.

    Cup:

    1. Bristol (4/7): 8.82
    2. Talladega (4/28): 8.62
    3. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    4. Richmond (4/13): 7.86
    5. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    6. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    7. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    8. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    9. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    10. Dover (5/6): 6.26
    11. Fontana (3/17): 4.41

    Xfinity:

    1. Bristol (4/6): 8.52
    2. Talladega (4/27): 8.16
    3. Richmond (4/12): 8.14
    4. Texas (3/30): 7.60
    5. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    6. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    7. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    8. Dover (5/4): 6.23
    9. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    10. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  24. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    We have a new leader....

    Cup:


    1. Kansas (5/11) 8.98
    2. Bristol (4/7): 8.82
    3. Talladega (4/28): 8.62
    4. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    5. Richmond (4/13): 7.86
    6. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    7. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    8. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    9. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    10. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    11. Dover (5/6): 6.26
    12. Fontana (3/17): 4.41
     
  25. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    It won’t be a part of the running list, but the Open got an average rating of 9.37 and the ASR got an 8.38. For any rating that was just a single number, I counted that as an ASR vote.
     
  26. Johali

    Johali Team Owner Contributor

    They were so much better than the last few years that we had to give them honorable mention in their own category. Thanks again for doing this.
     
    JJ_14, Kiante and ToyYoda like this.
  27. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    No problem at all. I’m glad they were able to vastly improve a race that’s been a turd the last several years.
     
  28. StandOnIt

    StandOnIt Farm Truck

    The Smith's are pretty shrewd operators. Plenty of stick um and tire dragging all week long to widen the groove.
     
    ToyYoda likes this.
  29. AuzGrams

    AuzGrams Team Owner

    I didn't watch 2018 ASR but 2019 was one of the better AS races in a while. 2009 was great obviously.
     
  30. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Kansas (5/11) 8.98
    2. Bristol (4/7): 8.82
    3. Talladega (4/28): 8.62
    4. Charlotte (5/26): 8.22
    5. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    6. Richmond (4/13): 7.86
    7. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    8. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    9. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    10. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    11. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    12. Dover (5/6): 6.26
    13. Fontana (3/17): 4.41

    Xfinity:

    1. Bristol (4/6): 8.52
    2. Talladega (4/27): 8.16
    3. Richmond (4/12): 8.14
    4. Charlotte (5/25): 7.85
    5. Texas (3/30): 7.60
    6. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    7. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    8. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    9. Dover (5/4): 6.23
    10. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    11. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  31. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Kansas (5/11) 8.98
    2. Bristol (4/7): 8.82
    3. Talladega (4/28): 8.62
    4. Charlotte (5/26): 8.22
    5. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    6. Richmond (4/13): 7.86
    7. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    8. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    9. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    10. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    11. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    12. Dover (5/6): 6.26
    13. Fontana (3/17): 4.41
    14. Pocono (6/2): 4.21

    Xfinity:

    1. Bristol (4/6): 8.52
    2. Pocono (6/1): 8.30
    3. Talladega (4/27): 8.16
    4. Richmond (4/12): 8.14
    5. Charlotte (5/25): 7.85
    6. Texas (3/30): 7.60
    7. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    8. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    9. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    10. Dover (5/4): 6.23
    11. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    12. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  32. Kiante

    Kiante Team Owner

    Mmm... That hurt me looking at that rating damn man.
     
    JJ_14 and ToyYoda like this.
  33. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    It was a rough one. A lot of 2’s, 3’s, and 4’s this week.
     
    JJ_14 and Johali like this.
  34. ChexOrWrex

    ChexOrWrex Ya gotta wanna

    So @Revman ’s 100,000,000 outlier rating didn’t make up ground huh :D
     
    Last edited: Jun 5, 2019
  35. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Lol, no. You’d think that would have made it at least 9.97 gajillion.
     
  36. kyle18fan

    kyle18fan Proud member of Rowdy Nation Contributor


    @Revman has math issues :lol2: his one and only flaw
     
    Revman and ToyYoda like this.
  37. ToyYoda

    ToyYoda Team Owner Contributor

    Cup:

    1. Kansas (5/11) 8.98
    2. Bristol (4/7): 8.82
    3. Talladega (4/28): 8.62
    4. Charlotte (5/26): 8.22
    5. Atlanta (2/24): 7.97
    6. Richmond (4/13): 7.86
    7. Daytona (2/17): 7.79
    8. Phoenix (3/10): 7.41
    9. Martinsville (3/24): 7.39
    10. Las Vegas (3/3): 7.21
    11. Texas (3/31): 6.79
    12. Dover (5/6): 6.26
    13. Michigan (6/10): 6.09
    14. Fontana (3/17): 4.41
    15. Pocono (6/2): 4.21

    Xfinity:

    1. Bristol (4/6): 8.52
    2. Pocono (6/1): 8.30
    3. Talladega (4/27): 8.16
    4. Richmond (4/12): 8.14
    5. Charlotte (5/25): 7.85
    6. Texas (3/30): 7.60
    7. Fontana (3/16): 7.42
    8. Las Vegas (3/2): 7.40
    9. Michigan (6/8): 6.89
    10. Atlanta (2/23): 6.65
    11. Dover (5/4): 6.23
    12. Phoenix (3/9): 4.64
    13. Daytona (2/16): 3.25
     
  38. Truex_rox

    Truex_rox 19 looks better than ever.

    Michigan scored higher than Pocono? Well I'll be.
     
    ToyYoda likes this.
  39. Speedbowl14

    Speedbowl14 Ryan Preece and short tracks

    The "big tracks" (Pocono, Michigan, Fontana) where this package was supposed to shine has been an absolute flaming disaster.
     
  40. ReturnTrip

    ReturnTrip Team Owner

    The 750hp package hasn't been great, either. Martinsville, Phoenix, Dover, and Richmond were all pretty forgettable.
     

Share This Page