Six Hendrick cars on the track this year and five of them made the chase. This speaks volumes to me. Jr. was a great driver not too many years ago but the last three years he has not produced.
I just can't see Mr. Hendrick giving up on him soon considering the sponsor money he brings in.
OK, I'm a sucker, and I did the research.
In 2000,
Dale JR: 2w, 3 T5, 5 T10
Steve Park: 1w, 6 T5, 13 T10
Best driver in 2000 is Steve Park.
In 2001,
Dale JR: 3w, 9 t5, 15 t10
Steve Park/Kenny Wallace: 1w, 6 t5, 14 t10
Michael Waltrip: 1w, 3 t5, 3 t10
Best Driver in 2001 is JR
In 2002
Dale JR 2w, 11 t5, 16 t10
Steve Park/Kenny Wallace: 0w, 0 t5, 3 t10
Michael Waltrip: 1 w, 4 t5, 10 t10
Best Driver in 2002 is Jr
In 2003
Dale JR 2w, 13 t5, 21t10
Steve Park/ Kenny Wallace/Jason Keller/John Andretti 0w, 0 t5, 1 t10
Michael Waltrip 2w, 8 t5, 11 t10
Best driver in 2003 is Jr (but it's close)
2004
JR 6w 16 t5 21 t10
Michael Waltrip 2w, 8 t5, 11 t10
Best driver in 2004 is Jr
2005
JR 1w 7 t5 13 t10
Michael Waltrip 0w, 3 t5, 7 t10
Best driver in 2005 is Jr
2006
Jr 1w, 10 t5, 17 t10
Truex 0w, 2 t5, 5 t10
Best driver is Jr
2007
Jr 0w, 7 t5, 12 t10
Truex 1w, 7 t5, 14 t10
Best driver is Truex
2008
Jr 1w 10 t5 16 t10
Casey Mears 0w 6 t5, 20 t10
Jimmy Johnson 7w, 15 t5, 22, t10
Jeff Gordon 0w, 13t5, 19t10
Best drivers are clearly JJ and Gordon
So in summary, JR has outdriven Mikey, Steve Park, and Martin Truex when he was a rookie. Also, he consistently wins 1 or 2 races a season, only exceeding that twice.