I totally agree with those two on how the FIA has continually screwed up F1 with it's constant rule changes.
Not to even mention sportscar racing. The shift to hybrid units in both F1 and WEC had driven the costs through the roof. The FIA's obsession with all things green is killing the sport.
As of right now, only Toyota
might be coming back to WEC, but I suspect that's because they haven't made the announcement yet that they aren't. There is no one to race against because Porsche and Audi simply packed up and left. The hybrid WEC is so expensive that no other manufacturers ever even gave it a look. How can you have a manufacturers championship with no manufacturers? Well, you can't, that is, unless you can do it with just one manufacturer. Toyota can't afford to stay because they can't win. If they win races against the slow, underfunded ByKolles, remember
they are supposed to beat them. And if Toyota loses, well, that's not
supposed to happen, is it?
Not content that they have almost totally killed off prototype racing, the FIA is going to change the rules again for 2020. They don't seen to understand whenever you change the rules the teams have to redesign, build new cars, refit all of their equipment, and drop a ton of scratch.
Now F1 is proposing a budget cap, but all that is going to do is cause people to lose their jobs. You have a lot of fixed costs in racing where you just can't cut back, but you can drop personnel. What you are going to end up with is cars that are still super complex and super expensive, but not enough money to have the proper amount of quality people to run them. It seems to me a better idea would be to make the cars less expensive, but the FIA seems hell bent on showcasing so much technology that no one can afford to race any more.
If you look at how miserably WEC has failed, you will get some insight into how short sighted the FIA really is. They are so blind that they can't see the answer that is right under their noses, and in fact, actually
in their hands. They already have a healthy, quality field of P2 cars ready to go. All they need to do is adopt IMSA's DPI rules. This way the current field will now become the top class, with current cars remaining competitive and manufacturers allowed to supply engines and bodykits. The current teams wouldn't have to do anything but show up, and they would be competing for overall wins, and surely there would be new teams interested in using manufacturer kits. If the affordable P2 class were top become the top division, it's not had to image the grids would swell up to the bursting point.
The FIA could have very easily made this adjustment the moment Porsche hinted they were pulling out, but instead, they stuck to their guns convinced that no one could possibly have a better idea than them.
How very French of them. Now, no one has time to plan ahead, convert current cars, or even put a new team together. Meanwhile, IMSA's DPI seems set to become a modern day Group C/GTP with new cars and teams being announced on an almost weekly basis. Still DPI is based on the FIA's P2 concept with a few tweaks. They had a really good idea....they just executed it badly. P2 is succeeding quite well as a second division prototype class, but it really should have been the premier division all along.
Sorry to be so long winded on this, but I wanted to lay the foundation of an argument that the FIA really has no business running world class motorsports. When you look at what they have already done to ruin world class motorsports, it's hard to see a rosy future for F1 if they continue down the road they are on.