jaqua19
Team Owner
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2015
- Messages
- 11,657
- Points
- 883
Let me prephase this by saying, yes, I did use chatgpt to help organize and proofread my writing.
Anyways...
There has been a lot of discussion surrounding Joey Logano’s place in the Championship 4 this season, with many fans arguing that his performance doesn’t merit a shot at the title. Given this discourse, I decided to analyze his performance, using a statistical model to rank the top 16 drivers of the Gen 7 era (2022–2024).
Rather than ranking every driver, because that would take far too long, I chose what I believe to be the top 16. Using their stats across multiple categories, I built a comprehensive weighted ranking that balances individual success, playoff performance, and consistency.
---
Each driver’s weighted score is based on a variety of performance metrics that are crucial to success in the current playoff system. Here are the categories and their assigned weights:
Championships (15%):
Championships matter, but since NASCAR’s format relies on a one-race championship, I opted not to give it the highest weight.
Race Wins (25%):
Winning is crucial in NASCAR. A win not only locks drivers into the playoffs but also advances them through rounds. Winning is the goal—so it receives the highest weight.
Top 5s (10%) and Top 10s (10%):
Consistency still plays a role, though not as significant as wins. Top 5s and 10s reflect how often a driver is in contention or near the front of the field, earning points throughout the season.
Laps Led (5%):
Laps led demonstrate how often a driver runs at the front, but since leading doesn’t guarantee wins or playoff advancement, it has a smaller weight.
Average Finish (5%):
This category reflects consistency over the entire season. However, in NASCAR’s playoff format, average finish doesn’t significantly impact the standings.
Playoff Wins (20%):
Postseason wins are vital. Winning a playoff race automatically advances drivers, making them incredibly valuable in the current system.
Final Four Appearances (10%):
Reaching the Championship 4 means a driver was consistent and played the playoff system well enough to have a 1-in-4 chance at the title. This metric reflects performance at the highest level of the playoffs.
---
Logano’s Performance: Breaking Down the Metrics
Below is the table of the top 16 drivers ranked by their weighted scores, including key performance metrics across Championships, Wins, Top 5s, Top 10s, Laps Led, Playoff Wins, Final 4 Appearances, and Average Finish:
---
Logano’s Metrics and Rankings
Here’s how Joey Logano ranks across the key categories:
Championships: Tied for 1st
Race Wins: Tied for 3rd
Playoff Wins: 2nd
Top 5 Finishes: 8th
Top 10 Finishes: 9th
Laps Led: 8th
Average Finish: 10th
Final 4 Appearances: Tied for 1st
His average category ranking across these metrics is 5.25.
Using the weighted formula, Logano’s overall ranking score places him 2nd among all drivers in the Gen 7 era (2022–2024).
---
Is Logano Undeserving?
While it’s true that Logano’s 2024 season is statistically the weakest for a Championship 4 contender, the argument that he doesn’t deserve to be there doesn’t hold up under scrutiny.
Here’s why:
1. Performance Across Three Seasons:
Logano has been consistently competitive throughout the Gen 7 era. His overall performance in championships, wins, and playoff success justifies his position among the top drivers and these are the most important categories within the context of the current format.
2. Clutch Playoff Performances:
Logano’s 4 playoff wins—2nd most of the Gen 7 era—highlight his ability to deliver under pressure. His success in the playoffs shows that he plays the system effectively, earning his spot in the Final 4.
3. Top-Tier Rankings Across Key Metrics:
Logano ranks in the top 3 in many critical categories, including championships, race wins, and playoff wins. Even though his average finish is lower, the weight of his playoff success and wins places him near the top overall.
4. Playing the System Well:
Logano’s two Final 4 appearances reflect his ability to consistently contend for championships in a playoff environment. In today’s NASCAR, being clutch in key moments carries more weight than pure season-long consistency.
---
Logano is a Deserving Final 4 Contender
While Logano’s 2024 season may not stand out statistically, his overall body of work during the Gen 7 era places him among the very best drivers of the past three years.
Weighted Score: 2nd among Gen 7 drivers.
Multiple top-tier rankings in critical categories, including championships, wins, and playoff success.
Ultimately, Logano’s ability to succeed when it matters most—particularly in the playoffs—justifies his place in the Championship 4. His critics may question his spot this season, but the data suggests that Logano has earned his place among the elite drivers in NASCAR’s modern era.
If you believe that Logano being ranked second is indicative of faulty weight, I hear you! It can always be altered. Feel free to merge with the Logano thread
Anyways...
There has been a lot of discussion surrounding Joey Logano’s place in the Championship 4 this season, with many fans arguing that his performance doesn’t merit a shot at the title. Given this discourse, I decided to analyze his performance, using a statistical model to rank the top 16 drivers of the Gen 7 era (2022–2024).
Rather than ranking every driver, because that would take far too long, I chose what I believe to be the top 16. Using their stats across multiple categories, I built a comprehensive weighted ranking that balances individual success, playoff performance, and consistency.
---
Each driver’s weighted score is based on a variety of performance metrics that are crucial to success in the current playoff system. Here are the categories and their assigned weights:
Championships (15%):
Championships matter, but since NASCAR’s format relies on a one-race championship, I opted not to give it the highest weight.
Race Wins (25%):
Winning is crucial in NASCAR. A win not only locks drivers into the playoffs but also advances them through rounds. Winning is the goal—so it receives the highest weight.
Top 5s (10%) and Top 10s (10%):
Consistency still plays a role, though not as significant as wins. Top 5s and 10s reflect how often a driver is in contention or near the front of the field, earning points throughout the season.
Laps Led (5%):
Laps led demonstrate how often a driver runs at the front, but since leading doesn’t guarantee wins or playoff advancement, it has a smaller weight.
Average Finish (5%):
This category reflects consistency over the entire season. However, in NASCAR’s playoff format, average finish doesn’t significantly impact the standings.
Playoff Wins (20%):
Postseason wins are vital. Winning a playoff race automatically advances drivers, making them incredibly valuable in the current system.
Final Four Appearances (10%):
Reaching the Championship 4 means a driver was consistent and played the playoff system well enough to have a 1-in-4 chance at the title. This metric reflects performance at the highest level of the playoffs.
---
Logano’s Performance: Breaking Down the Metrics
Below is the table of the top 16 drivers ranked by their weighted scores, including key performance metrics across Championships, Wins, Top 5s, Top 10s, Laps Led, Playoff Wins, Final 4 Appearances, and Average Finish:
---
Logano’s Metrics and Rankings
Here’s how Joey Logano ranks across the key categories:
Championships: Tied for 1st
Race Wins: Tied for 3rd
Playoff Wins: 2nd
Top 5 Finishes: 8th
Top 10 Finishes: 9th
Laps Led: 8th
Average Finish: 10th
Final 4 Appearances: Tied for 1st
His average category ranking across these metrics is 5.25.
Using the weighted formula, Logano’s overall ranking score places him 2nd among all drivers in the Gen 7 era (2022–2024).
---
Is Logano Undeserving?
While it’s true that Logano’s 2024 season is statistically the weakest for a Championship 4 contender, the argument that he doesn’t deserve to be there doesn’t hold up under scrutiny.
Here’s why:
1. Performance Across Three Seasons:
Logano has been consistently competitive throughout the Gen 7 era. His overall performance in championships, wins, and playoff success justifies his position among the top drivers and these are the most important categories within the context of the current format.
2. Clutch Playoff Performances:
Logano’s 4 playoff wins—2nd most of the Gen 7 era—highlight his ability to deliver under pressure. His success in the playoffs shows that he plays the system effectively, earning his spot in the Final 4.
3. Top-Tier Rankings Across Key Metrics:
Logano ranks in the top 3 in many critical categories, including championships, race wins, and playoff wins. Even though his average finish is lower, the weight of his playoff success and wins places him near the top overall.
4. Playing the System Well:
Logano’s two Final 4 appearances reflect his ability to consistently contend for championships in a playoff environment. In today’s NASCAR, being clutch in key moments carries more weight than pure season-long consistency.
---
Logano is a Deserving Final 4 Contender
While Logano’s 2024 season may not stand out statistically, his overall body of work during the Gen 7 era places him among the very best drivers of the past three years.
Weighted Score: 2nd among Gen 7 drivers.
Multiple top-tier rankings in critical categories, including championships, wins, and playoff success.
Ultimately, Logano’s ability to succeed when it matters most—particularly in the playoffs—justifies his place in the Championship 4. His critics may question his spot this season, but the data suggests that Logano has earned his place among the elite drivers in NASCAR’s modern era.
If you believe that Logano being ranked second is indicative of faulty weight, I hear you! It can always be altered. Feel free to merge with the Logano thread
