1. Hello, Guest, We regret to inform the community to Johali's passing.
    Please see This Thread. Thank you.
    Dismiss Notice

Nascar Hall of Fame 2020

Discussion in 'NASCAR chat' started by StandOnIt, Mar 14, 2019.

  1. StandOnIt

    StandOnIt Farm Truck

  2. Johali

    Johali Team Owner Contributor

    Tony Stewart
    Ricky Rudd
    Neil Bonnett
    Bobby Labonte
    Harry Gant
    Joker likes this.
  3. Snappy D

    Snappy D 2017 Pick Em Champion 2018 Bold Predictor

    Is Dale Earnhardt’s old crew chief Kirk Shelmerdine in the HOF? Is he nominated? He won 4 Winston Cups and was obviously pretty successful with Dale
    DaBiff1618 likes this.
  4. MRM

    MRM Team Owner

    He is not in and has not been nominated yet.
  5. Turtle84

    Turtle84 gained a step

    Tony Stewart is a no brainer, no discussion needed.
    Speedbowl14 likes this.
  6. nascarwoman

    nascarwoman Admin Staff Member

    Buddy Baker
    Harry Hyde
    Ralph Moody
    Tony Stewart
    Waddell Wilson
    jws926 likes this.
  7. Snappy D

    Snappy D 2017 Pick Em Champion 2018 Bold Predictor

    wow I find that kind of surprising
  8. Old 97

    Old 97 Team Owner

    The first Non-Cup Class

    Sam Ard
    Red Farmer
    Hershel McGriff
    Larry Phillips
    Mike Stefanik
    jws926 and dirtfan like this.
  9. aunty dive

    aunty dive Team Owner

    THE list.
  10. Kiante

    Kiante Team Owner

    Sam Ard is considered one of the greatest drivers of all time who didn't compete in Cup.

    A lot of his peers said he was a great driver, just didn't move to the next level. Ralph Moody should get in no problem IMHO. I mean he beat some great names during his time.

    Man, I wish I was alive to see some of these drivers and engineers. I really missed out on some great names in history.
  11. Johnny G

    Johnny G Team Owner

    They're running out of people already.

    Tony Stewart is the only one on that list that is definitely a no doubt HOFer
    Turtle84 likes this.
  12. Turtle84

    Turtle84 gained a step

    If they have a base of HOF'ers they're satisfied with, they may want to consider reducing the number they let in each year.
    LewTheShoe and Seedy like this.
  13. Turtle84

    Turtle84 gained a step

    Tony Stewart
    Bobby Labonte
    Harry Hyde
    Waddell Wilson
    Buddy Baker
  14. TexasRaceLady

    TexasRaceLady Plank Owner Contributor

    A question was asked of Mike Joy about Kirk being "removed" from the list. Here is Mike's answer ---

    Mike Joy‏Verified account @mikejoy500

    After a lengthy discussion of eligible candidates, each voter hand writes 20 names on their ballot, and the highest 20 vote getters are nominated. There is no "removal".
    Johali likes this.
  15. Johnny G

    Johnny G Team Owner

    Yeah. They cant keep putting 5 guys a year.
    Ron Hornaday is in it and no offence but the truck series shouldn't get you in the HOF
  16. SpeedPagan

    SpeedPagan The iRacing Guru

    I mean, it's a Top Three NASCAR series. It should count.
  17. StandOnIt

    StandOnIt Farm Truck

    Guthrie dropped from nominees for contributions to NASCAR
    Her removal was a surprise to Guthrie, who turned 81 last week.

    “Surely the nominees for 2020 haven’t been announced yet?” she replied in an email to The Associated Press. “I find that I was nominated for the Landmark Award of 2017 and 2018 as well as 2019. I’ve no idea what their reasoning is in selecting candidates

  18. Johnny G

    Johnny G Team Owner

    I have to disagree.
    I've always been of the opinion that for the Hall to actually mean something it should like other hall of fames and be very difficult to get in. Only the truely great. In NASCAR for me that means Cup series. As good as Xfinity and Truck races can be theyre still the minor league.
  19. Ventisca

    Ventisca Team Owner

    IDK, it seems very difficult to recognize the contributions and merit of individuals for a "Hall of Fame" with so many different perspectives -- and voting it in seems to make it a political (high school) exercise.

    They should've started with a Hall of Champions -- then build out other recognition from there.
  20. StandOnIt

    StandOnIt Farm Truck

    4 Truck series championships, three season top 5's in Xfinity and he did a lot to help many drivers get their start in Nascar. Yeah he earned his spot.
    Blaze, DaBiff1618 and jws926 like this.
  21. jws926

    jws926 I need to think of something new for here

    If it were named, NASCAR Cup Series Hall Of Fame, I would be in 100% agreement with you, but its not, so I can't .

    Just because most of Ron's success came in the lower series does not diminish his accomplishments.
    Old 97 and Blaze like this.
  22. Larsonfan1995

    Larsonfan1995 Team Owner

    It's time to reduce the classes to 3 people. Pretty soon Michael Waltrip will be a nominee if they don't slow down.
    Ventisca and jws926 like this.
  23. aunty dive

    aunty dive Team Owner

  24. KodiakRusty89

    KodiakRusty89 Team Owner

    Bobby Labonte - Busch and Cup Champion. His career hit the wall quickly but for a 10-15 year period he was great in NASCAR's top two series.
    Tony Stewart - No Brainer
    Ricky Rudd - His consistency was nearly unmatched. He also had solid success as an owner/driver.
    Mike Stefanik - He's a modified legend in the Northeast.
    Marvin Panch - Helluva driver who won the Daytona 500 and World 600 in dated equipment. One of the first guys from California to make a big splash.
    Turtle84 likes this.
  25. gnomesayin

    gnomesayin Team Owner

    I would say that it absolutely does diminish the accomplishments, relative to Cup standards. I'm not going to equate four Truck championships to a single Cup championship.

    However, it doesn't negate the accomplishments. A strong case can also be made that the Trucks were a tougher series during most of Hornaday's prime than it is now. As you say, it is not just the Cup HoF, and it is good to recognize the sport's most impactful figures at each major level.
    DaBiff1618 likes this.
  26. jws926

    jws926 I need to think of something new for here

    Comparing it to the Cup level, so of course it would diminish it , but that is like comparing a V8 to a four banger, not really fair.
  27. DaBiff1618

    DaBiff1618 Team Owner

    It’s the nascar hall of fame, not the cup series hall of fame. Not sure why some people can’t undedstand that lol. There’s so many local legends and great drivers from local and national touring series throughout the country that deserve recognition. I’d like to see guys like Sam Ard get there due
    Old 97, Mike Crayne and Blaze like this.
  28. Snappy D

    Snappy D 2017 Pick Em Champion 2018 Bold Predictor

  29. Greg

    Greg 2014 RF YAHOO CHAMP Your leader

    Not sure why Geoff Bodine is not one of the 20 nominated. I can understand that he would never be one of 20 most popular, he seemed quirky and l could not relate to him. But his driving was worthy of a HoF spot imo. He was great in New England Modifieds, and the Grand National series leading up to a Cup ride.
    He also did a dreat job for HMS in 1985 with the first year team. They went to Martinsville that year just about dollared out like so many have before. Bodine won the race, and in time HMS went on to be dominant. Who knows what would have happened to HMS with a different driver in 1985.
    I realize he isn't a first ballot entry type, Dale and Rusty were better but he is still HoF worthy imo.
  30. Speedbowl14

    Speedbowl14 Ryan Preece and short tracks

    Yeah if you only look at the guys on the track...there's a lot of great people in this sport who aren't drivers that are unmatched in their field for their respective ability.
    Blaze likes this.
  31. StandOnIt

    StandOnIt Farm Truck

    Old 97 likes this.
  32. Yogisd1

    Yogisd1 Resident Retard

    It makes no difference to me. Like everything else that is NASCAR, it's a popularity contest. This is why the the people that were the foundation of the sport, and the early innovators, are left off the list.

Share This Page