What did you think of the Martinsville call?

What should NASCAR have done at the end of Martinsville?

  • They got it right, penalize Bell

    Votes: 18 33.3%

  • They should've penalized Bell and Byron

    Votes: 24 44.4%

  • They should've penalized just Byron

    Votes: 1 1.9%

  • Nobody should've been penalized.

    Votes: 11 20.4%
  • Total voters
    54
Speedbowl14

Speedbowl14

Ryan Preece and short tracks
Joined
May 18, 2014
Messages
4,228
Points
743
Location
SLC, Utah
Curious what others are thinking about tonight's officiating call...

I was thinking Bell and Byron should've been penalized. Both manufacturers played games. NASCAR totally ignored that but is able to claim they did "something" by penalizing Bell for safety (but not competition).
 
I think DQing bell was perfectly fine, I said it the second it happened he rode the wall and to DQ him. That being said, if there is undeniable proof that the Chevy teams did anything to help Byron, he also should be DQed.
 
While both manufacturers tried to control the situation, neither Bell nor Byron are responsible for the actions of the #1, #3, or #23. Unlike Bowyer's 'sneeze', Bell and Byron weren't aided by teammates of the same owner.

Byron didn't break any rules. In NASCAR's opinion (and mine), Bell rode the wall. They got it right.

Me, I'd have sent all five to the back and put Larson in.
 
AndyMarquisLive said:
I say: Offsetting penalties. Finish stands.

That or penalize both and put Larson in.
Click to expand...
Only fair since there was interference on both sides.

Byron didn’t do anything wrong; neither did Truex years ago, but he got the short end of the stick in the form of getting booted from the chase because MWR’s interference was thrown in for his benefit.
 
Truex_rox said:
Only fair since there was interference on both sides.

Byron didn’t do anything wrong; neither did Truex years ago, but he got the short end of the stick in the form of getting booted from the chase because MWR’s interference was thrown in for his benefit.
Click to expand...
Truex’s career almost ended because of that too.
 
Blaze said:
Reddick has been one of the best all season, the **** you mean? He literally was the regular season champion lol
Click to expand...

Thanks to Larson being forced to sit a race?

None of these drivers bring flavor to the table. No Larson, no Bell, no Hamlin. It's like winning a chamnpionship with a handicap.

This system NASCAR has going for it its garbage. Has been for 20 years. Shoot, I'll take the "Chase" format with the 10 races without reset over the segmented 3 races per.
 
I don't think a penalty should have been issued.

Disclosure: I didn't agree with banning the hail melon, as long as it doesn't wreck another car.

I think Wallace, the trust fund, and Bowman should be investigated and disciplined if needed, but I wouldnt change the finishing order of today's race.
 
AndyMarquisLive said:
I say: Offsetting penalties. Finish stands.

That or penalize both and put Larson in.
Click to expand...
Offsetting yes. So no penalty there

But after those are offset, the wall ride is next to be looked at separately.

So they got it right there.
 
Reck said:
Thanks to Larson being forced to sit a race?

None of these drivers bring flavor to the table. No Larson, no Bell, no Hamlin. It's like winning a chamnpionship with a handicap.

This system NASCAR has going for it its garbage. Has been for 20 years. Shoot, I'll take the "Chase" format with the 10 races without reset over the segmented 3 races per.
Click to expand...
Lmao even then Reddick would’ve finished 2nd in the regular season 😂 you said none of the 4 deserve it, and they struggled all season long. That’s completely false. Hell even Byron was one of the best if you look at full season points. So tell me how either of them haven’t been one of the best all season long? I’ll wait.
 
Reck said:
Thanks to Larson being forced to sit a race?

None of these drivers bring flavor to the table. No Larson, no Bell, no Hamlin. It's like winning a chamnpionship with a handicap.

This system NASCAR has going for it its garbage. Has been for 20 years. Shoot, I'll take the "Chase" format with the 10 races without reset over the segmented 3 races per.
Click to expand...
Actually beating Logano AND Blaney would make either Reddick or Byron pretty deserving using that logic just based on their resume.
 
Reck said:
None of these drivers bring flavor to the table.
Click to expand...
I watch drivers for competence. When I want flavor, I have plenty of hot sauce.

According to the rules, at least three of the four met the qualifications. The rules say nothing about 'flavor'. I don’t like the playoffs but these drivers did what was required.
 
Reck said:
Thanks to Larson being forced to sit a race?

None of these drivers bring flavor to the table. No Larson, no Bell, no Hamlin. It's like winning a chamnpionship with a handicap.

This system NASCAR has going for it its garbage. Has been for 20 years. Shoot, I'll take the "Chase" format with the 10 races without reset over the segmented 3 races per.
Click to expand...
Forced?

Larson chose to run Indianapolis instead of Charlotte.

I think drivers should be allowed to miss races, but the rule in place was prevented for this very reason, to prevent guys like Tony Stewart (at the time) from going off and running a dirt race if they were in.

But it was good publicity so it was allowed.
 
Charlie Spencer said:
I watch drivers for competence. When I want flavor, I have plenty of hot sauce.

According to the rules, at least three of the four met the qualifications. The rules say nothing about 'flavor'. I don’t like the playoffs but these drivers did what was required.
Click to expand...

NASCAR literally came up with this playoffs shtick preciseley to provide entertainment. It's WWE on wheels.

Haven't figured it out by now? Dont get heated because I pointed out the best drivers are out of contention because of a system that leans into entertainment rather than competition based on who is best.
 
AndyMarquisLive said:
I say: Offsetting penalties. Finish stands.

That or penalize both and put Larson in.
Click to expand...
I would love either to be honest.

Still bitter about Larson.

Most wins. Most laps lead. Most stage wins... But wait for it ... Points leader without reset.

Two wins in the playoffs, most laps lead in the playoffs, and has had race winning cars in 3/4 of the 9 races.

This should be his second championship season, and him not even being able to race for one ultimately because of pit road issues at Vegas and a blown tire at Homestead costing him stage points is very difficult to swallow.

It's just **** luck.

It's all done and over with, but I'm hoping some sort of change. Based on performance, no one in the final 4 deserves it over Larson, and he would be in it without those freak issues in the round of 8.

It blows.
 
jaqua19 said:
I would love either to be honest.

Still bitter about Larson.

Most wins. Most laps lead. Most stage wins... But wait for it ... Points leader without reset.

Two wins in the playoffs, most laps lead in the playoffs, and has had race winning cars in 3/4 of the 9 races.

This should be his second championship season, and him not even being able to race for one ultimately because of pit road issues at Vegas and a blown tire at Homestead costing him stage points is very difficult to swallow.

It's just **** luck.

It's all done and over with, but I'm hoping some sort of change. Based on performance, no one in the final 4 deserves it over Larson, and he would be in it without those freak issues in the round of 8.

It blows.
Click to expand...

This is how Kevin Harvick fans felt in 2020, especially with the Texas rain BS.

But most fans forgave that when The Chosen One won the championship.
 
Reck said:
Dont get heated because I pointed out the best drivers are out of contention because of a system that leans into entertainment rather than competition based on who is best.
Click to expand...
I'm not heated. As far as the playoff system goes, I agree with you.

This is how the current rules define who 'deserves' to compete to be 'best'. You and I can like what we want but the drivers can only race under the rules they're given. They'd be idiots to race as if the 'total points' or 'last ten races' were in effect. Indeed, they'd probably be fired. Rage against it all you want but it is what it is.

Regardless, no system is going to guarantee the 'best' drivers are also the ones with the most 'flavor'.
 
Bell didn’t really net anything and certainly didn’t intend to wall ride, but by the book it’s an illegal wall ride and a good call. The Chevy rolling blockade is another deal entirely. Everything and everyone involved in that stinks and should be DQ’d themselves. Radio comms indicated as much, but whatever.
 
AndyMarquisLive said:
This is how Kevin Harvick fans felt in 2020, especially with the Texas rain BS.

But most fans forgave that when The Chosen One won the championship.
Click to expand...
And that evened out when Chase lost one he should’ve won. Harvick still a few short, but he won in 2014 when was the 5th best driver, and Jeff Gordon got boned out of another one. Sadly it happens. I much rather have a full season as well by the way.
 
I don’t think Bell on the fence was blatant. He got into the fence after he passed Bubba. But…Bubba rolling out of the gas for a fake tire going down was blatant.
Chastain and Dillon blocking for the 24 was also blatant.
Fooking clown parade.
 
Blaze said:
And that evened out when Chase lost one he should’ve won. Harvick still a few short, but he won in 2014 when was the 5th best driver, and Jeff Gordon got boned out of another one. Sadly it happens. I much rather have a full season as well by the way.
Click to expand...
Gordon was the best driver under the Lattford system which is not used anymore. Harvick was always going to win in 2014. Using the eye test, he was the best driver that year.

This is why I can’t stand discussing the playoffs in here. You Hendrick fans always defend the indefensible.
 
BobbyFord said:
I don’t think Bell on the fence was blatant. He got into the fence after he passed Bubba. But…Bubba rolling out of the gas for a fake tire going down was blatant.
Chastain and Dillon blocking for the 24 was also blatant.
Fooking clown parade.
Click to expand...
Doesn’t matter, rules are rules. Maybe if he was forced into the wall, it would be one thing. But rather you do something on purpose or not can’t go into the ruling, because then anyone can just do it and say that they didn’t do it. As far as him being ahead, that doesn’t matter either. The rule has nothing to do with if you get an advantage from it. The rule is that you can’t do it, point blank.
 
Blaze said:
Doesn’t matter, rules are rules. Maybe if he was forced into the wall, it would be one thing. But rather you do something on purpose or not can’t go into the ruling, because then anyone can just do it and say that they didn’t do it. As far as him being ahead, that doesn’t matter either. The rule has nothing to do with if you get an advantage from it. The rule is that you can’t do it, point blank.
Click to expand...
Do you believe the 1 and 3 blocked for the 24?
 
AndyMarquisLive said:
This is how Kevin Harvick fans felt in 2020, especially with the Texas rain BS.

But most fans forgave that when The Chosen One won the championship.
Click to expand...

Which is what will happen if Byron wins it this year.
 
Reck said:
This has to be the most lame, vanilla last 4 ever.

None of these 4 drivers deserved to be in. Strugglers all season long and all it takes is luck wins to get in. Terrible
Click to expand...
Blaney and Byron have both had really respectable seasons, but they certainly haven’t felt like title seasons - more like ~ Top 5 performances. Reddick was very solid for two-thirds of the year but felt like a paper tiger until he proved me wrong on the final lap last week, so I’d be okay with him winning when you also factor in the MJ and lawsuit angles. Logano is super whatever, of course.

More to your point, it’s not a foursome with a lot of star power. Without looking over previous ten years, I’d argue the least amount of star power yet. Combine that with the absolute stench of how everything unfolded at the end today, and I’m actually glad I have social obligations next weekend.
 
AndyMarquisLive said:
Gordon was the best driver under the Lattford system which is not used anymore. Harvick was always going to win in 2014. Using the eye test, he was the best driver that year.

This is why I can’t stand discussing the playoffs in here. You Hendrick fans always defend the indefensible.
Click to expand...
Lmao. Andy, buddy, I’m not defending anything? I said Chase shouldn’t have won in 2020, but he should have in 2022, which evens out. I’m not even a Gordon fan, and was HAPPY(no pun intended) Harvick won in 2014, you can go see the post from then. I’m just saying this system has screwed a lot of people, some of them then won championships years they shouldn’t have. Get over yourself
 
BobbyFord said:
Do you believe the 1 and 3 blocked for the 24?
Click to expand...
That has nothing to do with the wall ride.

But let’s say it happened, Bubba helped Bell, so as mentioned that offset each other or should. Then Bell broke rule as well on top of being helped. But as I said also, if Byron was DQed, I would’ve understood that.
 
Blaze said:
That has nothing to do with the wall ride.

But let’s say it happened, Bubba helped Bell, so as mentioned that offset each other or should. Then Bell broke rule as well on top of being helped. But as I said also, if Byron was DQed, I would’ve understood that.
Click to expand...
Just answer the question
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom