First, I went after that example because it's the one Cholo brought up in his question.Context my friend, context - it seems some will take any opportunity to take a swipe at another series.
You specifically cited an example of how to cut costs, and then followed with your reasoning of why it would be a bad idea:
"...For example, say you save money by dropping the dedicated pit crewmen and have the mechanics to do double-duty. You lose the ability for those crewmen to practice pit stops during the week. They're too busy doing their mechanic duties getting the car ready. If you have them practice stops, they may not have time to get the car up to snuff, or to stay up to date with changes in their specialties.."
And I cited 3 examples of other series that have the mechanics double as the pit stop crew. F1, WEC, and DTM. ( we can add all GT and touring car racing around the world and IMSA)
Thus providing specific examples that the argument made by you that having the mechanics do double-duty would not work was simply ill-informed. Because they get it done in other series in which the cars are just as, if not more complex, in what is needed to prepare them for racing.
That these series cost more to run a car is completely irrelevant. They are racing under different rules-sets - but they still don't have 'specialist' pit crews for a reason - it would drive costs up even more!
And if they can do it, there is no reason Nascar can't implement the same policy and save the teams some coin.
.
Pretty sure Charlotte just removed a whole grandstand in turn 3/4Our 2 seats at the Coke 600, Dover I and a few other races this year will be at full capacity. And we'll be enjoying it to the fullest.
Brian France and a couple of members here believe that racing has never been better than today. I am not making this up.
First, I don't appreciate your insults. They are inappropriate and completely unnecessary, so please stop them!The funny thing with Brian France and his couple of minions is they claim the racing today is better than ever so lets suspend reality and pretend they are correct. What good is the best racing ever if people are tuning out Nascar in droves?
Excellent post. I understand and appreciate the widespread sense of nostalgia for a favorite era of the sport, often a simpler time and coincidentally a time when we had our youth intact. What I don't get is the expectation that someone in charge of the sport could have and should have frozen time in that era, like stopping the clocks or something. Complaining that the world is not like it was when we were children or young adults is a futile thing and a waste of time.I have never really understood the NASCAR fans. They complain a lot. I get being frustrated with the product and the gripes that come with changes, but times evolve and things cannot always stay the same. I am a huge Baseball fan and I believe in the eye for an eye "unwritten rules" of the game, but I have a very real understanding of how antiquated that line of thinking is in today's game. NASCAR fans have resisted modification and change at nearly every turn. For me, the product itself is still very much entertaining, but I find many different things that make it fun for me. It isn't just about the racing. Obviously, you have the personalities, but I think you have to have a real interest in a driver. For me, I was always a Bobby Labonte fan, but when he went to smaller funded teams and was winding down his career I struggled with the sport because there wasn't a driver every week that I needed to pull for. I'm a CA guy who watched Larson come through the ranks, so when he got a shot it made sense to me. It is always nice to see a local kid make it. It makes it a little more real. I watch religiously every week and we get to track a year for a CUP race. Not every race is going to be exhilarating and every fan will watch for different reasons and feels like their style of racing is better then the other. I am a short track guy myself. I just like to see guys beat and bang and get their elbow's up. I like slick, sliding side by side grind it out racing. However, I went to Fontana last year and if we could get all mile and a half tracks or larger to race like that place we would be just fine. I just have never really understood the refusal to evolve.
A cost cap seems like it would be difficult to police/audit. What team expenses do you think would be regulated?If F1 and WEC, DTM, can have their mechanics do double duty on pit stops - Nascar should be able to do it as well.
It should be a no-brainer for cost cutting.
100% agreement on this.
Why there is no cost cap on the individual car teams is a mystery. While the top teams spend about 20 million per car - I'd imagine the actual practical cost could be several millions less. A good place to start on discussing a cost cap.
.
They're both difficult in their own way - in IMSA you're doing tires, refueling, and sometimes driver changes all at the same time. In all honesty it's kinda dangerous in a way as sometimes the drivers are still tightening their belts as they're exiting the pit lane. There was an incident at PLM in 2014 due to this.WEC? Aren't they like IMSA, where one of the biggest factors affecting pit stop speed is often a driver change? No point in going much faster than that happens. Apples and oranges.
First, I don't appreciate your insults. They are inappropriate and completely unnecessary, so please stop them!
Second, your point is a classic non sequitur. If other forms of racing were thriving while people turned away from Nascar, you would have a point. But that is not the case. MotoGP is trending well (in Europe and Asia, not in the US) from a low point just five years ago. But other than that, essentially all forms of racing are suffering revenue shortfalls and audiences that are tiny and/or declining. The distinction between "What's wrong with Nascar" and "What's happening to motorsports across the globe" is crucial to an intelligent discussion.
Pretty sure Charlotte just removed a whole grandstand in turn 3/4
and they are adding this in turn 4 bad azz if ya ask me
The 42,000 square-foot deck will include food and beverage service, restroom facilities, picnic and high-top table areas and a sprawling concourse for live music, corn hole and other entertainment, the speedway said in a statement Friday.
The new deck will be powered by a 960-panel elevated solar farm. The speedway also said the project is expected to be ready in time for 10 Days of NASCAR Thunder, which runs May 19-28.
http://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/business/article145953609.html
Touched on this before, I think this is a great idea. Hope it takes off, could be a future concept for tracks.and they are adding this in turn 4 bad azz if ya ask me
The 42,000 square-foot deck will include food and beverage service, restroom facilities, picnic and high-top table areas and a sprawling concourse for live music, corn hole and other entertainment, the speedway said in a statement Friday.
The new deck will be powered by a 960-panel elevated solar farm. The speedway also said the project is expected to be ready in time for 10 Days of NASCAR Thunder, which runs May 19-28.
http://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/business/article145953609.html
...
Second, how are we defining the word 'mechanic'? I'm using in the sense of the guys in the shop who build the cars. Any chance you're using it to describe the travelling engine, tire, shock, and other specialists?
Third, I can't speak to most of those series, but the F1 schedule has 20 races, most of which have at least two weeks between them, not 39 races with only 3 open weekends. There's a lot more time to prep the cars and still fit in time for pit practice.
...
Fourth, F1 has what, 10 crewmen over the wall, each with exactly one duty, and maybe three stops in a race? The tires and crew are already in place when the driver pulls in, and there's currently no refueling. No coordination between tire carrier and tire changer, no staying out of the gas man or jack man's way, no climbing over the wall, one nut per wheel instead of five, no bringing tires and equipment with you or carrying them away before the car can leave, no sticking wrenches through the window to make adjustments between trips around the car. There's a lot less to practice. Oh, and don't F1 teams travel with a bigger crew than NASCAR? That's more people to draw from, meaning less impact on each one's 'regular' job. WEC? Aren't they like IMSA, where one of the biggest factors affecting pit stop speed is often a driver change? No point in going much faster than that happens. Apples and oranges.
...
If it could be done without affecting competitive performance, don't you think they'd already be doing it so they could spend the money elsewhere?
I notice the article doesn't mention how many people will be served by this deck. I suspect it's far, FAR fewer than the number seated in grandstand it replaces.and they are adding this in turn 4 bad azz if ya ask me
The 42,000 square-foot deck will include food and beverage service, restroom facilities, picnic and high-top table areas and a sprawling concourse for live music, corn hole and other entertainment, the speedway said in a statement Friday.
The new deck will be powered by a 960-panel elevated solar farm. The speedway also said the project is expected to be ready in time for 10 Days of NASCAR Thunder, which runs May 19-28.
http://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/business/article145953609.html
Yeah, but it's just sports.It would be awesome if everyone shared the same opinion on the direction of the sport.
Some are ok regardless of what changes are made and some hate every change.
Why? You could ask that question about any number of sports rules. That's just the way those series operate. MIght as well ask why F1 teams don't use pit stop specialists; I suspect they would if they thought there was an advantage.... The part in italics is what I find completely ridiculous in Indycar and Nascar.. Why??? Just put the airgun boom out there let the pit crew get in position and let the car roll in and out. Why make it slower than it has to be. ( Even then there is still a huge amount of teamwork in an F1 pit-stop, you don't do a 2 second stop without tons of practice and coordination. ) ... The Nascar teams did it precisely because it gave a competitive edge over the teams who would not. But now days everyone does it. So just ban the pit specialists and it will be be the same for everybody..
I notice the article doesn't mention how many people will be served by this deck. I suspect it's far, FAR fewer than the number seated in grandstand it replaces.
As much as Charlotte charges for everything,I'll have to pass.For sure as "enhancing the fan experience" just means "what can we do with all the seats that formerly sold out" but if it helps get young people to the track it will make the best of a bad situation. I may go to Charlotte so I can play some corn hole and hopscotch for the edgy experience if nothing else.
That's the downside. The upside is being two rows up from that same drunk and bouncing chicken bones off his noggin, then turning around and pretending to see where they came from. THAT IS WHAT KEEPS THIS SPORT ALIVE AND WHY IT WILL NEVER DIE!“Fans want to feel that sense of community. They want the flexibility to leave their seats to interact with other fans and have fun, but they still want to stay on top of the action,” Smith said.
Heh, heh, heh…… Oh my….
Ya wanna get up ‘n go back two rows to slap the poo-pay out of the drunk that keeps standin’ up ‘n splashin’ beer on the folks in front.
Is playing hopscotch the hot new tailgating activity? That must be a hoot to watch the drunks play.
I am SO out of touch.
As much as Charlotte charges for everything,I'll have to pass.
“Fans want to feel that sense of community. They want the flexibility to leave their seats to interact with other fans and have fun, but they still want to stay on top of the action,” Smith said.
Heh, heh, heh…… Oh my….
Ya wanna get up ‘n go back two rows to slap the poo-pay out of the drunk that keeps standin’ up ‘n splashin’ beer on the folks in front.
Hate to disappoint, it ain’t my game.
Not our seats though. They're still there and will be occupied during the race.Pretty sure Charlotte just removed a whole grandstand in turn 3/4
Okay, here's a paper bag. Hold it over your mouth and just breathe in and out slowly...Ok let me give my opinion, I'm new to the sport this is my second year watching... let me start off by saying I always loved speed and cars.. I just couldn't ever see myself watching cars go around in a circle! I remember growing up hating the fact that they showed NASCAR on ESPN and just couldn't understand it.. I always thought it's only driving a car anybody that could drive a car could do what there doing in a race car.. anyways I moved to Charlotte like 6 years ago and would ride by the speedway every now and then and thought it looked amazing because it was HUGE! So one day something just made me want an old school racing jacket lol.. so I started to do my research at work and found some jackets I like.. so I was like you know what instead of just getting a jacket give the sport a chance since u love fast cars , SO I DID!! And boy was that the best decision I made in my LIFE!! This is coming from an African American that grew up on basketball and wasn't raised watching NASCAR! The sport is just awesome!! Everything to it.. how much it takes to wheel one of those cars the patience the focus.. what it takes to put it together.. the strategy.. sitting in those cars for hours doing 200 when it's 120 degrees in the car ... it's just amazing to me everything that goes into ur leading up to that Sunday! Not to mention you can go to the shops watch them build meet the drivers you feel apart of the team your going for ... I buy so much stuff they call me when new stuff come in and I just live mins away from the shop! You can watch the trucks leave with the cars to head out to tracks it's just amazing !! No other sport where u can be on the surface where the activity is about to take place before it does.. I went to DAYTONA this year got pit passes and almost passed out when I got in the infield and just looked around it was beautiful Plus I got to sign the track it was just amazing experience I'll never forget. These guys put there lives on the line every Sunday at those speeds man it's just something I think everyone should experience.. NOW is NASCAR DYING?! I have been to a lot of races already and when I go it's a tone of people there.. I think what's hurting the sport the most IS US!! All the complaining everyday !! I never seen a sport where fans complain so much! LISTEN PEOPLE ITS 2017!!! TIMES HAVE CHANGED!! PRICES HAVE GONE UP!!! GET OVER IT!!! It's not going back to 1950 or whateva it's JUST NOT!!! The racing this year have been great but people want the old days back so much you will just say you hate it when actually it's been good racing !! Complaining about cable complaining about tickets!! Come on it's 2017 everything went up in prices.. your killing a great sport with all the complaining!! Complaining about toyato being in cup and being mad because it's not American come on man really?!! All of this complaining it's the sport worst enemy!!
You can't
A cost cap seems like it would be difficult to police/audit. What team expenses do you think would be regulated?
Other sports leagues that have caps have them only on player salary. Those contracts are easy to see and enforce. Those leagues don't cap spending on any other aspect of team expenses. I don't see how NASCAR could control spending on R&D, engine and chassis testing, etc. If I share my test results with satellite teams, can I divide the expense six ways?I don't think it's impossible. Again, F1 is trying to implement one and we should all pay close attention to how that goes. If that league can do it with all their insane politics then NASCAR can no problem. Step one would be to have all contracts filed with the league office and published, the transparency alone will help even things out a little. Drivers, most CC's, sponsors, and from what I've seen pit crew members on some teams all work on a contract basis. That makes it much easier to place a salary/spending cap for those aspects. Remember, in many cases it was the players unions which pushed leagues to adopt salary caps, not the owners. Now the shop workers, the R&D centers, the manufacturer programs, engine builders... that's where we need to take a cue from F1.
Other sports leagues that have caps have them only on player salary. Those contracts are easy to see and enforce. Those leagues don't cap spending on any other aspect of team expenses. I don't see how NASCAR could control spending on R&D, engine and chassis testing, etc. If I share my test results with satellite teams, can I divide the expense six ways?
Ok let me give my opinion, I'm new to the sport this is my second year watching... let me start off by saying I always loved speed and cars.. I just couldn't ever see myself watching cars go around in a circle! I remember growing up hating the fact that they showed NASCAR on ESPN and just couldn't understand it.. I always thought it's only driving a car anybody that could drive a car could do what there doing in a race car.. anyways I moved to Charlotte like 6 years ago and would ride by the speedway every now and then and thought it looked amazing because it was HUGE! So one day something just made me want an old school racing jacket lol.. so I started to do my research at work and found some jackets I like.. so I was like you know what instead of just getting a jacket give the sport a chance since u love fast cars , SO I DID!! And boy was that the best decision I made in my LIFE!! This is coming from an African American that grew up on basketball and wasn't raised watching NASCAR! The sport is just awesome!! Everything to it.. how much it takes to wheel one of those cars the patience the focus.. what it takes to put it together.. the strategy.. sitting in those cars for hours doing 200 when it's 120 degrees in the car ... it's just amazing to me everything that goes into ur leading up to that Sunday! Not to mention you can go to the shops watch them build meet the drivers you feel apart of the team your going for ... I buy so much stuff they call me when new stuff come in and I just live mins away from the shop! You can watch the trucks leave with the cars to head out to tracks it's just amazing !! No other sport where u can be on the surface where the activity is about to take place before it does.. I went to DAYTONA this year got pit passes and almost passed out when I got in the infield and just looked around it was beautiful Plus I got to sign the track it was just amazing experience I'll never forget. These guys put there lives on the line every Sunday at those speeds man it's just something I think everyone should experience.. NOW is NASCAR DYING?! I have been to a lot of races already and when I go it's a tone of people there.. I think what's hurting the sport the most IS US!! All the complaining everyday !! I never seen a sport where fans complain so much! LISTEN PEOPLE ITS 2017!!! TIMES HAVE CHANGED!! PRICES HAVE GONE UP!!! GET OVER IT!!! It's not going back to 1950 or whateva it's JUST NOT!!! The racing this year have been great but people want the old days back so much you will just say you hate it when actually it's been good racing !! Complaining about cable complaining about tickets!! Come on it's 2017 everything went up in prices.. your killing a great sport with all the complaining!! Complaining about toyato being in cup and being mad because it's not American come on man really?!! All of this complaining it's the sport worst enemy!!
Okay, here's a paper bag. Hold it over your mouth and just breathe in and out slowly...
Good stuff.
Yet another article reviewing the business of Nascar. It is a good review, perhaps the best of the week, but I'll spare you from starting another redundant thread...
(from SBNation)
NASCAR’s troubles aren’t over yet, but there is finally reason for optimism
The optimism is not unfounded, but Monster Energy is the key.
Along with the enhanced racing brought about by the three-stage format and updated aero package, NASCAR has an impressive crop of young drivers that it can build around for years to come. Many times over, Kyle Larson and Chase Elliott have demonstrated they are outwardly talented, much in the fashion Stewart and Gordon did before them.
Within the industry the hope is Monster Energy, the new entitlement Cup Series sponsor, will be the bridge that brings NASCAR to a fresh, younger audience that may not have familiarity with stock car racing. The energy drink company is expected to be the conduit that effectively markets the 24-year-old Larson and the 21-year-old Elliott into the crossover stars that NASCAR is lacking, following the departures of Gordon, Edwards, Stewart, and soon, Earnhardt.
Being NASCAR’s biggest partner is a role Monster has grown increasingly comfortable with, after an initial ramp-up period brought about by the deal between the two parties not being finalized until December. Monster’s fan zone display at various tracks has included an appearance by Rob Gronkowski at the season-opening Daytona 500, a stunt motorcycle shows, MMA fights at the upcoming All-Star Race....
The harsh reality, however, is Larson and Elliott are still not close to being the next mainstream breakout stars that NASCAR desperately needs. They may each be brilliant behind the wheel, but they have a long way to go in the charisma department that compels the casual observer to watch them race on Sundays. And if neither can assume that mantle, then the television ratings and attendance figures seen at Richmond will become the norm. A standard no one within the industry is prepared to deal with.