All-Star race experimentation receives mostly high marks

Mispeedway15

Team Owner
Joined
May 22, 2016
Messages
1,953
Points
243
I’m not sure why HP needs to be lessened but you should be able to mess with the cars aerodynamically to make them get a draft better
 

DUN24

Skeptical of the Spectacle
Joined
Feb 24, 2013
Messages
15,683
Points
883
Ah, trotting out the old "listening to the fans" canard again.

They are listening to themselves squawk in an echo chamber.

I wish Mark Martin had a bigger platform, because he is on point.
They literally can’t find a driver in support of the changes. It’s comical.


The number of fans in support of changes seems to be decreasing by the day. During the all star race r/NASCAR was creaming themselves, they’ve come to their senses recently it appears.
 

Switchback

Team Owner
Joined
Dec 15, 2014
Messages
347
Points
273
They literally can’t find a driver in support of the changes. It’s comical.


The number of fans in support of changes seems to be decreasing by the day. During the all star race r/NASCAR was creaming themselves, they’ve come to their senses recently it appears.
This place was screaming in support of it immediately after the all star race. The rate the race ratings were through the roof from the majority. That seems to have died down some too. I'm guessing the drivers are swaying a few opinions. If the fastest car/driver on the track takes the lead and cannot drive away , I'm no longer interested in watching.
 

AdoubleU24

Team Owner
Joined
Mar 9, 2015
Messages
4,310
Points
593
I think people were OK with it until they heard the drivers exit the cars and talk about how easy it was. That was an unknown while the race was going on.
 

DUN24

Skeptical of the Spectacle
Joined
Feb 24, 2013
Messages
15,683
Points
883
This place was screaming in support of it immediately after the all star race. The rate the race ratings were through the roof from the majority. That seems to have died down some too. I'm guessing the drivers are swaying a few opinions. If the fastest car/driver on the track takes the lead and cannot drive away , I'm no longer interested in watching.
Oh yes they were going ape**** over here too..
 

FLRacingFan

Team Owner
Joined
Feb 9, 2013
Messages
23,927
Points
883
Location
Florida
One of the big NASCAR PR employees is spin, spin, spinning this hard in the /r/NASCAR thread on the same article.

He actually said "fans overwhelmingly want this" followed a few comments later by "I don't have the data".

Unbelievable.

Edit: link -
 
Last edited:

DUN24

Skeptical of the Spectacle
Joined
Feb 24, 2013
Messages
15,683
Points
883
One of the big NASCAR PR employees is spin, spin, spinning this hard in the /r/NASCAR thread on the same article.

He actually said "fans overwhelmingly want this" followed a few comments later by "I don't have the data".

Unbelievable.

Edit: link -
Yup, he backed it up with fan council findings(of which he didn’t specify) that don’t exist as far as anyone can tell.
 

gnomesayin

Team Owner
Joined
Oct 14, 2013
Messages
5,727
Points
793
I think people were OK with it until they heard the drivers exit the cars and talk about how easy it was. That was an unknown while the race was going on.
I haven't seen commentary from anyone who liked the All-Star race but later was persuaded by negative driver reaction to not support it. Some of us had a good handle on the effects of greatly reducing power and increasing downforce and drag. Some were critical from the beginning, others have been enthusiastic about it. I think the drivers' voices should count and be taken seriously, certainly more so than certain media figures who are always dissatisfied and chasing the next fix. But the effect on driving difficulty was not an unknown mystery.
 

ChexOrWrex

Ya gotta wanna
Joined
May 19, 2013
Messages
21,021
Points
883
Brad Keselowski, the 2012 NASCAR Cup Series champion, has warned that such a direction has the potential to encourage the best drivers to eventually take their talents elsewhere.

where they going to go buckwheat, Joe Bob's short track?
Stay at the dirt levels instead of getting into asphalt.

If they still want to do asphalt they can always get into WRC, ARCA, IndyCar or not shoot for the Cup Series if they are interested in NASCAR. They have plenty of options.
 

Snappy D

2017 Pick Em Champion 2018 Bold Predictor
Joined
Feb 13, 2017
Messages
7,283
Points
693
Yuck. Yuck. Yuck. To Go from an awesome race Saturday back to this crap......I hope it’s not true.
 

Switchback

Team Owner
Joined
Dec 15, 2014
Messages
347
Points
273
Brad Keselowski, the 2012 NASCAR Cup Series champion, has warned that such a direction has the potential to encourage the best drivers to eventually take their talents elsewhere.

where they going to go buckwheat, Joe Bob's short track?
These guys could take what they have left of there star power and easily get another national touring series off the ground. Nascar would be nothing but a heap of rubble left in there wake. It won't happen, but they could.

In reality what I think will happen with any package that looks like the all Star plate fiasco is this; the top guys in the sport with nothing left to prove will move on since they can't outrun buckshot Jones anymore.

Also, Danica got into this sport a few years too early. She could have been a race win contender with the all Star package. You also may want to call Travis pastrana, Ricky Carmichael, and any other of the potential saviors of Nascars past. They'll all be able to win now . Heck, Nascar could even give them a little bit "special" plate to make sure they race up front.
 

LewTheShoe

Team Owner
Joined
Apr 21, 2016
Messages
3,537
Points
493
One of the big NASCAR PR employees is spin, spin, spinning this hard in the /r/NASCAR thread on the same article.

He actually said "fans overwhelmingly want this" followed a few comments later by "I don't have the data".
Personally, I hate the idea of dumbing down the difficulty of driving the cars and diluting the role of driver skill in the races. By your many posts, I am aware that you do as well. But I don't doubt for a minute that an overwhelming majority of Nascar fans prefer the All Star engine and aero rules over the "normal" 2018 rules that specify more power, less downforce, and less drag. You could start by reviewing comments in this thread...

Rate The All Star Races: Charlotte

It frustrates me, but I don't think the average Nascar fan even recognizes the difficulty of driving and racing these 2018 cars, nor does he care about it. The prevailing theory is... beating and banging and wrecking plus numerous passes for the lead is the definition of good racing, without regard for how it is obtained.

The membership here is not representative of all Nascar fans. In general, we tend to be more avid as fans, more knowledgeable about the sport, and less receptive to any change. But even here, I think its fair to say support for the All Star race was "overwhelming."

The job of Jim and Lesa France as owners and stewards of Nascar is not just to give the fans what they want, or what they think they want today. It is their job to protect and enhance the value of the brand over the long haul. They need to be smarter and better equipped (with data and business acumen) than the average fan. They need to realize that diluted, dumbed down racing will accelerate the decline of Nascar, not reverse it. The appeal of glossed up pack racing would be as fleeting as polyester leisure suits IMO, so I hope they don't go "all in" on that.
 

Snappy D

2017 Pick Em Champion 2018 Bold Predictor
Joined
Feb 13, 2017
Messages
7,283
Points
693
Personally, I hate the idea of dumbing down the difficulty of driving the cars and diluting the role of driver skill in the races. By your many posts, I am aware that you do as well. But I don't doubt for a minute that an overwhelming majority of Nascar fans prefer the All Star engine and aero rules over the "normal" 2018 rules that specify more power, less downforce, and less drag. You could start by reviewing comments in this thread...

Rate The All Star Races: Charlotte

It frustrates me, but I don't think the average Nascar fan even recognizes the difficulty of driving and racing these 2018 cars, nor does he care about it. The prevailing theory is... beating and banging and wrecking plus numerous passes for the lead is the definition of good racing, without regard for how it is obtained.

The membership here is not representative of all Nascar fans. In general, we tend to be more avid as fans, more knowledgeable about the sport, and less receptive to any change. But even here, I think its fair to say support for the All Star race was "overwhelming."

The job of Jim and Lesa France as owners and stewards of Nascar is not just to give the fans what they want, or what they think they want today. It is their job to protect and enhance the value of the brand over the long haul. They need to be smarter and better equipped (with data and business acumen) than the average fan. They need to realize that diluted, dumbed down racing will accelerate the decline of Nascar, not reverse it. The appeal of glossed up pack racing would be as fleeting as polyester leisure suits IMO, so I hope they don't go "all in" on that.
Well said. This package seems the wrong way to go, we’ll see what they come up with
 

ReturnTrip

Team Owner
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
1,494
Points
323
NASCAR will regret it when one team figures out the package and stinks up the show every week. You know damn well Rodney Childers will find a way.
 

AndyMarquisLive

Short Track Fanatic
Joined
Feb 16, 2009
Messages
63,235
Points
1,033
Location
A short track somewhere
Unable to address a stagnant schedule, NASCAR turns to polarizing competition package
The sanctioning body says they are listening to fans
https://autoweek.com/article/nascar/unable-address-stagnant-schedule-nascar-turns-polarizing-competition-package
This was a great article.
NASCAR will regret it when one team figures out the package and stinks up the show every week. You know damn well Rodney Childers will find a way.
It's gonna happen.
 

Joker

#1 Harvick Fan
Joined
Aug 17, 2018
Messages
1,043
Points
193
If this is true, consider my fandom of NASCAR postponed - perhaps cancelled altogether if this kills the sport entirely.
 

Charlie Spencer

Short tracks and road courses.
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
19,317
Points
883
Location
Lexington, SC
Brad Keselowski, the 2012 NASCAR Cup Series champion, has warned that such a direction has the potential to encourage the best drivers to eventually take their talents elsewhere.

where they going to go buckwheat, Joe Bob's short track?
Those who can afford to might retire. Those who can't will stick around.

The real issue is those drivers still coming up, esp. those who haven't reach the level of a national touring series yet. NASCAR doesn't have a monopoly on motorsports. They may go to open wheel, sports cars, sprint cars, etc; somewhere they feel is more challenging. The money may not be competitive but that doesn't seem to bother drivers already running in those series. The owners may decide to follow them or leave racing entirely, selling off to the Front Rows and Levines that are left.
 
Last edited:

Switchback

Team Owner
Joined
Dec 15, 2014
Messages
347
Points
273
Those who can afford to might retire. Those who can't will stick around.

The real issue is those drivers still coming up, esp. those who haven't reach the level of a national touring series yet. NASCAR doesn't have a monopoly on motorsports. They may go to open wheel, sports cars, sprint cars, etc; somewhere they feel is more challenging. The money may not be competitive but that doesn't seem to bother drivers already running in those series. The owners may decide to follow them or leave racing entirely, selling off to the Front Rows and Levines that are left.
The pay may not be an issue for long. If Nascar decides to run a large portion of there schedule as plate races, there may not be much money left for paying drivers in the future. Another series could easily end up being the premier series in time.

Even a 3 wide, fender rubbing, last lap pass for the lead will lose its luster if it happens on a weekly basis. Nothing is special anymore once it becomes common. Taking power away to force these guys to ride around in packs in some sort of chess match type race will lose its appeal quickly. I am willing to guarantee that after any initial spike that may occur, the nosedive that ratings will take shortly after will blow right by current lows.

Now if Nascar comes up with a package that doesn't get hung up in dirty air, but the faster car/drivers can drive away, that could be really cool. I'm not sure they want that though. In that scenario, once the fastest team on any given day finds the front, they are going to drive away just like the leader does now.
 

FLRacingFan

Team Owner
Joined
Feb 9, 2013
Messages
23,927
Points
883
Location
Florida
Personally, I hate the idea of dumbing down the difficulty of driving the cars and diluting the role of driver skill in the races. By your many posts, I am aware that you do as well. But I don't doubt for a minute that an overwhelming majority of Nascar fans prefer the All Star engine and aero rules over the "normal" 2018 rules that specify more power, less downforce, and less drag. You could start by reviewing comments in this thread...

Rate The All Star Races: Charlotte

It frustrates me, but I don't think the average Nascar fan even recognizes the difficulty of driving and racing these 2018 cars, nor does he care about it. The prevailing theory is... beating and banging and wrecking plus numerous passes for the lead is the definition of good racing, without regard for how it is obtained.

The membership here is not representative of all Nascar fans. In general, we tend to be more avid as fans, more knowledgeable about the sport, and less receptive to any change. But even here, I think its fair to say support for the All Star race was "overwhelming."

The job of Jim and Lesa France as owners and stewards of Nascar is not just to give the fans what they want, or what they think they want today. It is their job to protect and enhance the value of the brand over the long haul. They need to be smarter and better equipped (with data and business acumen) than the average fan. They need to realize that diluted, dumbed down racing will accelerate the decline of Nascar, not reverse it. The appeal of glossed up pack racing would be as fleeting as polyester leisure suits IMO, so I hope they don't go "all in" on that.
Look at this. One race with lower downforce and everyone convinced - convinced! - that it was the way to long-term. Then - it sucked. We hated lower downforce. I do not thinking NASCAR fans overwhelmingly support a particular package as much as they are fascinated by the latest shiny object. And I absolutely think there's been an about-face in support once fans realized they were being finessed and it wasn't just going to be for Indy or whatever, but for half the damn schedule. Drivers speaking out has helped as well. I would be shocked if any poll taken right now came anywhere close to data derived around the time of the All-Star Race.

 

FLRacingFan

Team Owner
Joined
Feb 9, 2013
Messages
23,927
Points
883
Location
Florida
nobody knows what the aero package is if there is one, but whatever it is they don't like it. ;)o_O
if Mr. Official NASCAR PR Guy is making the rounds on the Internet trying to justify this, it's happening. It's pretty clear what the setup will look like next season. It's just a matter of time before they announce it.
 

AdoubleU24

Team Owner
Joined
Mar 9, 2015
Messages
4,310
Points
593
Didn't the engineers ruin the low downforce package? If they could keep their paws off and stop undoing everything we'd probably still be happy lol.

They're going to screw with anything that NASCAR throws out there, including this garbage next year. I don't think we're ever going to see a cup series again where we're excited by the racing on a consistent basis. There will be plenty of bad, some good, and others great, and we'll just have to accept it.
 

Charlie Spencer

Short tracks and road courses.
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
19,317
Points
883
Location
Lexington, SC
Didn't the engineers ruin the low downforce package? If they could keep their paws off and stop undoing everything we'd probably still be happy lol.

They're going to screw with anything that NASCAR throws out there, including this garbage next year. I don't think we're ever going to see a cup series again where we're excited by the racing on a consistent basis. There will be plenty of bad, some good, and others great, and we'll just have to accept it.
That's what the owners pay the engineers to do - make the cars go faster. I'm not sure why you're blaming the engineers for doing their jobs, especially within the rules
 

AdoubleU24

Team Owner
Joined
Mar 9, 2015
Messages
4,310
Points
593
That's what the owners pay the engineers to do - make the cars go faster. I'm not sure why you're blaming the engineers for doing their jobs, especially within the rules
Oh I'm not, I'm saying we're too a point in this sport where teams are going to engineer their way out of whatever NASCAR throws at them which means that no matter the package, we're going to find ourselves having these discussions.
 

StandOnIt

Farm Truck
Joined
Feb 26, 2013
Messages
40,346
Points
883
Location
yoooklahoma
if Mr. Official NASCAR PR Guy is making the rounds on the Internet trying to justify this, it's happening. It's pretty clear what the setup will look like next season. It's just a matter of time before they announce it.
if it is so clear what is it?
 

Westy

Support local tracks
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
56
Points
98
Location
Barrie, Ontario
Idk how NASCAR can have a premier series with cars that crank out less horsepower than some of the "lower tier" series. What is the point of having a premier series that goes to large tracks if the power of the cars has to be choked down to less than a super late model?

Surely with the combined resources of NASCAR and their teams' engineers they can find a way to reduce the clean air advantage without making the cars slow af. There has to be some way of reducing the aero advantage of being the lead car without making it a disadvantage to be out front
 

Charlie Spencer

Short tracks and road courses.
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
19,317
Points
883
Location
Lexington, SC
Ah, IMS again. Hey, NASCAR, here's an idea. How about running on tracks your cars are suited to, instead of modifying the cars to suit the tracks?
 

LewTheShoe

Team Owner
Joined
Apr 21, 2016
Messages
3,537
Points
493
Ah, IMS again. Hey, NASCAR, here's an idea. How about running on tracks your cars are suited to, instead of modifying the cars to suit the tracks?
I for one am always intrigued by the Brickyard 400. I'm pumped up about the venues for the coming weeks, including trucks and Xfinity on two great road courses, then Indy, then Darlington. I believe current low downforce Cup cars *are* well-suited to Indy, although slashing the side force would make it even better. Indy is a drivers track... a stern test of skills as it should be. YMMV.
 
Top Bottom