I think it is funny that Mack is getting grief for simply saying what we all have witnessed. I also find a good bit of humor when a "mod" attempts to in a sense censor someone for simply stating an opinion in a discussion forum.........sometimes people don't need to be saved by the white knight moderator, especially when it's a simple discussion. The BS in here gets thick sometimes.
As for the elephant in the room. If anyone in here thinks that her racing career was a success you would be hard pressed to find any information that may convince anyone who values competitiveness that that was the case. In sports and competition success is, was and always will be measured by wins. How many of those does she have? In business she has been more successful then many and in life she has been more successful then most. Well, with the exception of her botched marriage, where in that category I am much better then her as I have yet to run my significant other off (ducks moderator's harpoon net).
You can sit back and say "at least she made it", but I would ask you to ask her, the competitor that we all watched give frustrated interviews if she thinks that her racing career was successful. I would be willing to bet that from a business, personal and overall achievement stand point she would say yes. But, if you then asked her if she ever thinks about what could have been.........she would understand that the answer there is a no. She gets it, she has competed her whole life, wins=success in that world.
I think that she is a lightning rod for this type of discussion because the hype was incredibly palpable due to the over exposure of her by the NASCAR media and her somewhat awkwardness towards the attention. She appears to not like the attention, yet she is more then happy to mug for the camera. She is a difficult person to read. Personally, I have never liked her. I have always felt that she came across as fake and unfortunately it is all that I have to go off of.
As for her bringing new fans into the sport. I would completely disagree. I think that unfortunately for NASCAR and a lot of motorsports if you are not introduced to the sport at some point by someone, a single personality/driver is not going to make you a fan of the sport. What generally happens is that you find someone or something that completes the cycle of making you a fan. I was a huge Bobby Labonte fan growing up, but when he basically retired I really struggled to find another driver to pull for. My overall interest in the sport waned a little bit on a national level, but when Larson started making noise I became even more interested then I was prior. Here is a guy from near where I am from, that I had watched come through the ranks and I personally liked on a personal level. You become more invested and thus, more of a fan and more willing to invest your own capital in the sport/driver.
I think Danica definitely did that. Little girls for instance typically(not always so don't burn your bras) will gravitate to the color pink. Obviously why a lot of girls have pink in their race cars. So when a little girl is introduced to NASCAR and as she is watching trying to find and make some sense of it they may see Danica and relate and then the full circle is completed. As far as people just turning on the TV to see Danica Patrick the female driver, maybe for the first few races, but once the results fail to live up to the hype and expectation, fair or not, those people are gone.